The contract given to Garoppolo shows the importance of having a quarterback under contract. Webb will be only one or two years from free agency if and when he takes over from Eli. Unless the Giants feel the the quarterbacks in this year's class are all over rated it does not make sense to trade down and pass up the opportunity to have a good quarterback on a controlled contract when they move on from Eli.
After Eli is gone the Giants will be paying their QB well below market value in which they have 3-4 years too strengthen the rest of the roster before they have to pay their new franchise QB.
Seattle was such a powerhouse for a few years because they were paying Russell Wilson very little for 3 years. The Eagles benefitted from paying Wentz way below market value. For the record I am not saying take a QB for this reason or just for the sake of taking a QB. If the Giants feel a QB has franchise potential then they should take him over any other position. If they don't like any of the QB's at 2 then they should trade down but stay in the top 10 to come away with either Barkley, Chubb, Nelson, or Edmunds. If they don't like the QB's this year they could acquire a 2019 1st and either a 2nd this year or next year as well to give them plenty of ammunition to get their QB if they need to trade up to get him next year.
Until this year, no one knew if Jimmy G could play either.
Outside the Giants. He had not thrown the ball in a game and this crop of qbs is seen as better than last years. He was drafted under the old regime which is far different than the new one.
Is Jimmy G worth the second overall pick?
In comment 13828444
Carl in CT said:
| Is Jimmy G worth the second overall pick?
Not at $137 MM